It is interesting to compare these two leading Australian Pinot Noirs I drank this week, even though they are of different age. They are the two brands with international Pinot Noir reputation.
Firstly, the 2020 Bass Phillip Estate Pinot Noir. Since the ownership change, the label is a little different; old vines is added. Is the wine different? This Pinot Noir is full-bodied, with flamboyant red and black cherry flavours. The wine is quite fruity, delivering a big mouthfeel, but there are also earthy notes, and smoky and salty flavours. This is quite Burgundian in a Vosne-Romanée style. The silky tannins have appeal, and the aromatic and expanding finish is excellent. The wine is
perhaps a bit fruity, but it has other attractive elements. It certainly tastes like a Bass Phillip of old.
Score: 94/++
The 2017 By Farr Sangreal Pinot Noir is also big fruited, with dark cherry and black fruited jam flavours. It is also quite savoury. This wine certainly packs a punch, maybe a bit too much, but the fine grained tannins compensate. The wine shows an attractive salinity and a long finish. It is ultimately well composed, and would appeal to Shiraz drinkers.
Score: 94/++
In terms of international recognition, these two wines would certainly come across as Australian wines, bigger fruited than Burgundy. The expanding finish is a hallmark of Bass Phillip, and only the best Burgundies show this well. There are aspects which could improve before I would call these world- class, but they are excellent examples of how far Australian Pinot Noir has come.
No comments:
Post a Comment